Nationwide Insurance Company

On December 17, Judge James C. Tormey of the New York Superior Court, Onandoga County, granted final approval to a $100 million settlement in this derivative class action lawsuit against the Nationwide Insurance Company. The case arose from injuries to consumers purchased the company’s life insurance policies. In approving the settlement, the Judge explicitly praised the litigation team:

“It was a pleasure to work with you. This is a good result. You’ve got some great attorneys working on it. Everybody, everybody made out fine.”

The lawsuit, in which Pomerantz served as Co-Lead Counsel for the plaintiff class, focused on how Nationwide used its “captive agency force”—its sales team of agents who worked exclusively for Nationwide and sold only its products – to market and its sell life insurance policies to consumers. Nationwide allegedly trained its captive agency force to use uniform marketing scripts, a deceptive practice in violation of state consumer protection statutes such as New York General Business Law § 349.

A key allegation against the company concerned Nationwide’s “vanishing premium” life insurance policies. Plaintiffs claimed that the company fraudulently marketed its flexible-premium or whole-life insurance policies with misleading, computer-generated sales illustrations. Also, Nationwide’s agents allegedly told consumers that they would only need to pay out-of-pocket premiums for a fixed number of years (e.g., 5 to 10 years), after which the policy’s dividends and interest would completely cover future premiums – in other words, the premium would “vanish.”

However, the “vanishing” mechanism would only work if the historic high-interest rates of the 1980s continued indefinitely, a critical condition that, plaintiff alleged, Nationwide intentionally omitted or obscured. When interest rates indeed fell in the 1990s, the company’s dividends failed to cover the costs, forcing consumers to pay massive, unexpected premiums to keep their policies from lapsing.

Case Name

Snyder v. Nationwide Ins. Co., No. 97/0633 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. Onondaga Cty. 1998)